4.4  Moments

“Give me a place to stand on, and I can move the earth.”

— Archimedes, as reported by Pappus of Alexandria, c. AD 340

A moment, also known as the torque can be described as a “force to generate a rotation”, as it generates an angular acceleration if not in ballance.

A moment has the unit Newton-meter [ Nm ], it is a vector, and appears around a point as the product of a moment arm (hävarm), \(d\), and an applied force, \(F\), perpendicular to the moment arm, see the figures below.

Moment in 2D and 3D

\[ \boxed{ \boldsymbol M_O = \boldsymbol r \times \boldsymbol F } \]

where \(\boldsymbol r\) is known as the moment arm, and \(\boldsymbol F\) is the applied force. The moment arm is the vector from the point of rotation to the line of action of the force. The direction of the moment is determined by the right-hand rule, which states that if you curl your fingers in the direction of rotation, your thumb will point in the direction of the moment.

The scalar counterpart

\[ M = F d \]

Figure 4.4.1: Two forms of the right-hand rule. Left: when the fingers curl in the sense of rotation, the thumb points along the moment vector. Right: with the index finger along \(\bm a\) and the middle finger along \(\bm b\), the thumb points along \(\bm a \times \bm b\).

We can derive the moment vector from Figure 4.4.2, which lays the components of \(\bm r\) and \(\bm F\) along the axes and builds the three moment components from them.

Figure 4.4.2: The moment of \(\bm F\) about \(O\), component by component. Each moment component turns about its axis, positive by the right-hand rule, and is built from the two force components across that axis and the two arm components that reach them.

\[ \boldsymbol{M}_O=\left[\begin{array}{l} M_x \\ M_y \\ M_z \end{array}\right]=\left[\begin{array}{c} F_z r_y-F_y r_z \\ F_x r_z-F_z r_x \\ F_y r_x-F_x r_y \end{array}\right]=\left[\begin{array}{c} F_z r_y-F_y r_z \\ -\left(F_z r_x-F_x r_z\right) \\ F_y r_x-F_x r_y \end{array}\right]=\boldsymbol{r} \times \boldsymbol{F} \]

The operator \(\times\) is known as the cross product or vector product, and in 3D for a moment arm vector and force vector the physical meaning is a moment vector. The cross product is a vector that is perpendicular to the plane formed by the two vectors being multiplied. The order of operation is important, according to the right-hand rule convention, the moment arm vector is the first vector.

\[ \boldsymbol M = \boldsymbol r \times \boldsymbol F = - \boldsymbol F \times \boldsymbol r \]

\[ \boldsymbol{M} \perp \boldsymbol{r} \text { and } \boldsymbol{M} \perp \boldsymbol{F} \]

Figure 4.4.3: Trivial examples of how the cross product works, showcasing the independency on the point of application along the line of application.

In sympy we compute the cross product by

import sympy as sp
F_x, F_y, F_z, r_x, r_y, r_z = sp.symbols('F_x, F_y, F_z, r_x, r_y, r_z', real=True)

FF = sp.Matrix([F_x, F_y, F_z])
rr = sp.Matrix([r_x, r_y, r_z])

MM = rr.cross(FF)
MM

\(\displaystyle \left[\begin{matrix}- F_{y} r_{z} + F_{z} r_{y}\\F_{x} r_{z} - F_{z} r_{x}\\- F_{x} r_{y} + F_{y} r_{x}\end{matrix}\right]\)

Example 1: Force perpendicular to its arm

Figure 4.4.4: A 10 N force at \(A\), perpendicular to the arm \(OA\).

Find the moment of \(\bm F\) about \(O\) in Figure 4.4.4. The force is perpendicular to the arm, so \(M_z = Fd\) with \(d = 3\) m, and \(\bm r\times\bm F\) must give the same.

from mechanicskit import ltx

F, d = 10, 3
rr = sp.Matrix([d, 0, 0])
FF = sp.Matrix([0, F, 0])

M_z = F*d
MM = rr.cross(FF)

\[ M_z = Fd = 30,\qquad \bm M = \bm r\times\bm F = \left[\begin{matrix}3\\0\\0\end{matrix}\right]\times\left[\begin{matrix}0\\10\\0\end{matrix}\right] = \left[\begin{matrix}0\\0\\30\end{matrix}\right] \]

Any \(\bm r\) ending on the line \(x = 3\) gives the same moment, since its \(y\) component is parallel to \(\bm F\).

Example 2: Force at an angle

Figure 4.4.5: A 10 N force at \(A\) along the slope 4:3.

Find the moment of \(\bm F\) about \(O\) in Figure 4.4.5.

Here \(\bm r_{OA}\) is not perpendicular to \(\bm F\), so \(\lvert\bm r_{OA}\rvert\) is not the lever arm. The lever arm \(d\) is the perpendicular distance from \(O\) to the line of action, \(OQ\) in Figure 4.4.6. The right triangle \(OQA\) gives

\[ d = \lvert\bm r_{OA}\rvert\sin\theta = \lvert\bm r_{OA}\times\bm e_F\rvert, \qquad M_z = Fd. \]

Figure 4.4.6: The lever arm \(d\) is the perpendicular from \(O\) to the line of action, with its foot at \(Q\).

Any point \(P\) on the line of action is \(\bm r_{OP} = \bm r_{OA} + t\,\bm e_F\), and since \(\bm e_F\times\bm F = \bm 0\),

\[ \bm r_{OP}\times\bm F = \bm r_{OA}\times\bm F + t\,\bm e_F\times\bm F = \bm r_{OA}\times\bm F. \]

t = sp.symbols('t', real=True)
ee_F = sp.Matrix([sp.Rational(4, 5), sp.Rational(3, 5), 0])   # exact, so no round-off
FF = 10*ee_F
rr_OA = sp.Matrix([4, -2, 0])

d = rr_OA.cross(ee_F).norm()
MM_A = rr_OA.cross(FF)
MM_P = (rr_OA + t*ee_F).cross(FF)

\[ \begin{aligned}d &= 4\text{ m}\\ \bm r_{OA}\times\bm F &= \left[\begin{matrix}4\\-2\\0\end{matrix}\right]\times\left[\begin{matrix}8\\6\\0\end{matrix}\right] = \left[\begin{matrix}0\\0\\40\end{matrix}\right]\\ \bm r_{OP}\times\bm F &= \left[\begin{matrix}\dfrac{4 t}{5} + 4\\\dfrac{3 t}{5} - 2\\0\end{matrix}\right]\times\left[\begin{matrix}8\\6\\0\end{matrix}\right] = \left[\begin{matrix}0\\0\\40\end{matrix}\right]\end{aligned} \]

The parameter \(t\) vanishes from \(\bm r_{OP}\times\bm F\), which gives the same vector, and \(M_z = Fd = 40\) Nm. A force may slide along its line of action without changing its moment.

Example 3: Moment of a force in space

Figure 4.4.7: The force \(\bm F\) acts at the point \(A\), 5 m along the \(x\) axis and 2 m above it.

Find the moment about \(O\) of the force \(\bm F = [-2,\ 1,\ -2]^\mathsf{T}\) N acting at \(A\) in Figure 4.4.7. In space the lever arm \(d\) is hard to read off a drawing, but the cross product of Chapter 3.7 needs only the arm \(\bm r_{OA}\) and the force. Row by row,

\[ \bm M_O = \bm r_{OA}\times\bm F = \begin{bmatrix} 5 \\ 0 \\ 2 \end{bmatrix}\times\begin{bmatrix} -2 \\ 1 \\ -2 \end{bmatrix} = \begin{bmatrix} 0\cdot(-2) - 2\cdot 1 \\ 2\cdot(-2) - 5\cdot(-2) \\ 5\cdot 1 - 0\cdot(-2) \end{bmatrix} = \begin{bmatrix} -2 \\ 6 \\ 5 \end{bmatrix}\text{ Nm}. \]

rr_OA = sp.Matrix([5, 0, 2])
FF = sp.Matrix([-2, 1, -2])

MM_O = rr_OA.cross(FF)

SymPy returns the same vector.

\[ \bm M_O = \bm r_{OA}\times\bm F = \left[\begin{matrix}5\\0\\2\end{matrix}\right]\times\left[\begin{matrix}-2\\1\\-2\end{matrix}\right] = \left[\begin{matrix}-2\\6\\5\end{matrix}\right]\text{ Nm} \]

Two properties of the cross product check the result. \(\bm M_O\) is perpendicular to both the arm and the force, so both dot products vanish, and its length is \(Fd\), so dividing by \(F\) gives the lever arm that the drawing hides,

\[ \bm M_O\cdot\bm r_{OA} = 0, \qquad \bm M_O\cdot\bm F = 0, \qquad d = \frac{\lvert\bm M_O\rvert}{\lvert\bm F\rvert}. \]

d = MM_O.norm()/FF.norm()

Both dot products vanish, and the lever arm is half the length \(\lvert\bm r_{OA}\rvert = \sqrt{29} \approx 5.39\) m of the arm.

\[ \bm M_O\cdot\bm r_{OA} = 0,\quad \bm M_O\cdot\bm F = 0,\quad d = \frac{\sqrt{65}}{3} \approx 2.687\text{ m} \]

Example 4: Moment about an axis through \(O\)

Figure 4.4.8: A bracket with the force \(F = 100\) N acting from \(A\) towards \(B\).

A turnbuckle at \(B\) tightens the wire from \(A\) to \(B\) in Figure 4.4.8 to \(F = 100\) N. Find the moment of the wire force \(\bm F\) about \(O\) and about the \(z\) axis. The force acts along the unit vector from \(A\) to \(B\), its moment about \(O\) uses any point on its line of action (Example 2), and the \(z\) component is the projection on \(\bm e_z\),

\[ \bm F = F\,\frac{\bm r_{OB}-\bm r_{OA}}{\lvert\bm r_{OB}-\bm r_{OA}\rvert}, \qquad \bm M_O = \bm r_{OA}\times\bm F, \qquad M_z = \bm M_O\cdot\bm e_z. \]

rr_OA = sp.Matrix([5, 0, 2])
rr_OB = sp.Matrix([3, 1, 0])
ee_z = sp.Matrix([0, 0, 1])

FF = 100*(rr_OB - rr_OA).normalized()
MM_O = rr_OA.cross(FF)
M_z = MM_O.dot(ee_z)

The point \(A\) and the direction from \(A\) to \(B\), \([-2,\ 1,\ -2]^\mathsf{T}/3\), are those of Example 3, so the wire force is \(100/3\) times the force there, and so is its moment, \(\bm M_O = \tfrac{100}{3}[-2,\ 6,\ 5]^\mathsf{T}\) Nm.

\[ \begin{aligned}\bm F &= \left[\begin{matrix}- \dfrac{200}{3}\\\dfrac{100}{3}\\- \dfrac{200}{3}\end{matrix}\right]\text{ N}\\ \bm M_O = \bm r_{OA}\times\bm F &= \left[\begin{matrix}5\\0\\2\end{matrix}\right]\times\left[\begin{matrix}- \dfrac{200}{3}\\\dfrac{100}{3}\\- \dfrac{200}{3}\end{matrix}\right] = \left[\begin{matrix}- \dfrac{200}{3}\\200\\\dfrac{500}{3}\end{matrix}\right]\text{ Nm}\\ M_z &= \dfrac{500}{3} \approx 166.7\text{ Nm}\end{aligned} \]

The line of action also passes through \(B\), so by Example 2 the arm \(\bm r_{OB}\) must give the same moment as \(\bm r_{OA}\). The two arms differ by a multiple of the force direction, \(\bm r_{OA} - \bm r_{OB} = 3\,\bm F/F\), and the cross product of \(\bm F\) with itself is zero,

\[ \bm r_{OB}\times\bm F = \bm r_{OA}\times\bm F - 3\,\frac{\bm F}{F}\times\bm F = \bm r_{OA}\times\bm F. \]

MM_OB = rr_OB.cross(FF)

The arm to \(B\) gives the vector found with the arm to \(A\).

\[ \bm r_{OB}\times\bm F = \left[\begin{matrix}3\\1\\0\end{matrix}\right]\times\left[\begin{matrix}- \dfrac{200}{3}\\\dfrac{100}{3}\\- \dfrac{200}{3}\end{matrix}\right] = \left[\begin{matrix}- \dfrac{200}{3}\\200\\\dfrac{500}{3}\end{matrix}\right]\text{ Nm} \]

Example 5: Moment about a skew axis

Figure 4.4.9: A bent pipe fixed at \(O\), with the force \(F = 120\) N acting from \(B\) towards \(C\).

Find the moment of \(\bm F\) about the axis \(OA\) in Figure 4.4.9, with \(F = 120\) N along \(BC\). As in Example 4, the moment about an axis is the projection of \(\bm M_O\) on the axis direction, now \(\bm e_{OA}\) in place of \(\bm e_z\),

\[ \bm F = F\,\frac{\bm r_{OC}-\bm r_{OB}}{\lvert\bm r_{OC}-\bm r_{OB}\rvert}, \qquad \bm M_O = \bm r_{OB}\times\bm F, \qquad M_{OA} = \bm M_O\cdot\bm e_{OA}. \]

rr_OA = sp.Matrix([1, 4, 0])
rr_OB = sp.Matrix([1, 4, 2])
rr_OC = sp.Matrix([5, 0, 0])

FF = 120*(rr_OC - rr_OB).normalized()
MM_O = rr_OB.cross(FF)
M_OA = MM_O.dot(rr_OA.normalized())

The step from \(B\) to \(C\) is \([4,\ -4,\ -2]^\mathsf{T}\) m, 6 m long, so \(\bm F = 20\,[4,\ -4,\ -2]^\mathsf{T}\) N, and the moment about the leg \(OA\) is \(M_{OA} = 800/\sqrt{17}\) Nm.

\[ \begin{aligned}\bm F &= \left[\begin{matrix}80\\-80\\-40\end{matrix}\right]\text{ N}\\ \bm M_O = \bm r_{OB}\times\bm F &= \left[\begin{matrix}1\\4\\2\end{matrix}\right]\times\left[\begin{matrix}80\\-80\\-40\end{matrix}\right] = \left[\begin{matrix}0\\200\\-400\end{matrix}\right]\text{ Nm}\\ M_{OA} &= \dfrac{800 \sqrt{17}}{17} \approx 194.0\text{ Nm}\end{aligned} \]

The pipe is held in the flange at \(O\), and the leg \(OA\) leaves the flange along \(\bm e_{OA}\). The flange carries the moment \(\bm M_O\), and the leg feels it in two ways. The part along its own axis twists it, and this is the torque about the axis. The rest is perpendicular to the axis and bends the leg. The projection of Chapter 3.6 makes the split, with the unit vector \(\bm e_{OA}\) in the role of the direction,

\[ \bm M_\parallel = (\bm M_O\cdot\bm e_{OA})\,\bm e_{OA} = M_{OA}\,\bm e_{OA}, \qquad \bm M_\perp = \bm M_O - \bm M_\parallel. \]

ee_OA = rr_OA.normalized()

MM_par = M_OA*ee_OA
MM_perp = MM_O - MM_par

The torque has the length \(M_{OA}\) and lies along the leg, and the bending moment carries the large \(z\) component of \(\bm M_O\).

\[ \begin{aligned}\bm M_\parallel &= \left[\begin{matrix}\dfrac{800}{17}\\\dfrac{3200}{17}\\0\end{matrix}\right] \approx \left[\begin{matrix}47.06\\188.2\\0\end{matrix}\right]\text{ Nm}\\ \bm M_\perp &= \left[\begin{matrix}- \dfrac{800}{17}\\\dfrac{200}{17}\\-400\end{matrix}\right] \approx \left[\begin{matrix}-47.06\\11.76\\-400.0\end{matrix}\right]\text{ Nm}\end{aligned} \]

The bending moment, \(\lvert\bm M_\perp\rvert \approx 403\) Nm, is about twice the torque, \(M_{OA} \approx 194\) Nm. The split checks itself in two ways. \(\bm M_\perp\) has no component along the leg, and since the two parts are perpendicular their squared lengths add up to that of \(\bm M_O\),

\[ \bm M_\perp\cdot\bm e_{OA} = 0, \qquad \lvert\bm M_\parallel\rvert^2 + \lvert\bm M_\perp\rvert^2 = \lvert\bm M_O\rvert^2 = 200\,000\ \text{N}^2\text{m}^2. \]

\[ \bm M_\perp\cdot\bm e_{OA} = 0,\quad \lvert\bm M_\parallel\rvert^2 + \lvert\bm M_\perp\rvert^2 = 200000\text{ N}^2\text{m}^2 \]